A fence dividing a city’s poorest from richest

By Alyssa Campbell

IMG_2126

When driving along Montreal’s Boulevard de l’Acadie, you might at first only notice on one side of the road a line of shrubs with suburban houses in the background. However, upon closer inspection, the existence of a six-foot tall chain-link fence separating Montreal’s poorest neighborhood from one of its richest becomes readily apparent. This fence, separating the Town of Mont-Royal and the neighborhood of Parc-Extension, is representative of the physical segregation that can occur even in a city like Montreal that has a long-standing reputation of tolerance, openness and diversity.

In 1960, residents of the Town of Mont-Royal lobbied for the construction of a fence along its border with Parc-Extension with the reason that it was absolutely necessary for the safety of their children against the traffic of the Boulevard de l’Acadie. However, to many the fence carries an obvious tone of intentional class segregation. It is a physical means to prevent the low-income residents of the neighborhood Parc-Extension from entering the affluent Town of Mont-Royal. In 1966, students from the Université de Montréal tore down parts of the fence in the midst of a riot, declaring it class separation. However, the fence was quickly restored by city officials. While politicians from Parc-Extension have made pledges to tear it down, the former Mayor of Mont-Royal stated that his constituents have a “psychological need” for the fence. During a recent Halloween, the fence’s gates were locked to prevent children from Parc-Extension from trick-or-treating in the Town of Mont-Royal. On a recent visit I made to the fence, the gates still remained locked – an ongoing message that no one, not even children, are welcome – if only because they come from Parc-Ex.

The fence aligning Boulevard de l'Acadie, with the Town of Mont-Royal on the left and Parc-Extension on the right

The fence aligning Boulevard de l’Acadie, with the Town of Mont-Royal on the left and Parc-Extension on the right

Looking across the fence into the Town of Mont-Royal from Parc-Extension

Looking across the fence into the Town of Mont-Royal from Parc-Extension

The reason given for the fence is for the "security" and safety of Mont-Royal's children

The reason given for the fence is for the “security” and safety of Mont-Royal’s children

The stark differences between Parc-Extension and the Town of Mont-Royal cannot be overemphasized. For their close physical proximity, the two neighborhoods are polar opposites. Although surrounded entirely by the city of Montreal, the Town of Mont-Royal has been its own municipality since it de-merged from the city in 2006. Its tree-lined streets, large single-family homes, and freshly mowed lawns are representative of how a privatized urbanity can emerge completely removed from its immediate surroundings. Mont-Royal came into being in 1912 as a planned corporate suburb, designed to be a model upper-class city reflecting the principles of the Garden City and City Beautiful movements. Meanwhile, Parc-Extension developed as a working-class neighborhood and key immigrant hub, welcoming successive waves of Italian, Greek and now predominately South Asian and Latin American immigrants.

The Boulevard de l'Acadie sign from the side of the Town of Mont-Royal

The Boulevard de l’Acadie sign from the side of the Town of Mont-Royal

The sign from the side of Parc-Extension

The same sign from the side of Parc-Extension, revealing the evident material differences between the neighborhoods

A sign protesting the racism evident in  Quebec's recent "Charter of Values," ironically located at the beginning of the fence

A sign protesting the racism evident in Quebec’s recent “Charter of Values,” ironically located near the beginning of the fence

Parc-Extension is among one of Canada’s most diverse neighborhoods, with over two-thirds of its population immigrants and visible minorities. In comparison, the population of Mont-Royal is nearly three-fourths white. While in Mont-Royal the average household income is over six-figures, in Parc-Extension the average income is barely over $30,000 – with nearly half of the population qualifying as low-income. In Parc-Extension, 78% of residents speak a mother tongue other than French and English, while in the Town of Mont-Royal only 1% does. Demographic differences, however, only brush the surface of the divide that runs between the two communities after more than five decades of physical separation.

Social interaction is key to overcoming such tensions, prejudices and fear of a visible “other” living next door. However, as long as the chain-link fence stands, opportunities for interaction between the residents of Mont-Royal and Parc-Extension are diminished and the fence will continue to reinforce the idea that the two communities are too irreparably different to ever be connected.

Photos property of the author.

Advertisements

Tags:

3 Comments on “A fence dividing a city’s poorest from richest”

  1. alexsommer April 18, 2014 at 1:38 pm #

    Great article and pictures. There are some interesting parallels here in NYC, too, between the Sea Gate neighborhood and Coney Island: http://goo.gl/maps/g8UDC

    Like

  2. Jennifer G April 21, 2014 at 12:38 pm #

    fascinating article about the hidden divisions that serve to maintain social divides. There must be parallels in many cities….

    Like

  3. Syed S. Ahmed July 16, 2014 at 6:40 pm #

    A really good post. A visitor may never notice the fence or its real purpose.

    Syed

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: